Covid 19 and the Family Court
Sir Andrew McFarlane, President of the Family Division, has today published ‘The Road Ahead’ for the Family Court in England and Wales“. This document lays out the framework for the Family Court over the next six months as it continues to adjust to the realities of managing a justice system during a pandemic.
We’re on a Road to Somewhere
In setting out the latest, and what he has now subtitled ‘Final’ route map for the Family Courts in the pandemic environment, Sir Andrew’s introduces the guidance thus,
“We have reached a juncture in the Family Court’s journey through the COVID 19 crisis when it is both possible and necessary to take stock and to consider the road ahead. It is possible to do this because, in contrast to the early weeks, there is now a bedrock of experience of remote working. This experience, both positive and negative, was in large part described and teased out in the enormously valuable and impressive report published by the Nuffield Family Justice Observatory on remote hearings in the Family Court in early May 2020. It is necessary to look at the road ahead because any earlier rose-tinted thoughts that ‘this will all be over by July’ have sadly evaporated and it is now clear that, whilst the situation of total lockdown may be gradually relaxed, the need for stringent social distancing restrictions is likely to remain for many months to come.
This document seeks to establish a broad framework for the Family Court by attempting to chart the road ahead over the next six months or more.”
In the document, the key message concenrs ‘Time Management’, and it outlines that a ‘significant change’ is needed.
Drawing the matters referred to above together, the following is clear:
i. The current restraints (or variants of them) are likely to obtain for many months to come;
ii. The volume of work in the system is very high;
iii. The Family Court was not coping with the pre-COVID workload and radical steps aimed at changing professional culture and working practices were about to be launched when the pandemic struck;
iv. The ability of the system to process cases is now compromised by the need to conduct most hearings remotely;
v. Whilst there will be some capacity for the courts to conduct faceto-face hearings, the available facilities will be limited;
vi. Remote hearings are likely to continue to be the predominant method of hearing for all cases, and not just case management or short hearings;
vii. Delay in determining a case is likely to prejudice the welfare of the child and all public law children cases are still expected to be completed within 26 weeks;
viii. Adjourning cases indefinitely or for a period of many months will not, therefore, be an option.
If the Family Court is to have any chance of delivering on the needs of children or adults who need protection from abuse, or of their families for a timely determination of applications, there will need to be a very radical reduction in the amount of time that the court affords to each hearing. Parties appearing before the court should expect the issues to be limited only to those which it is necessary to determine to dispose of the case, and for oral evidence or oral submissions to be cut down only to that which it is necessary for the court to hear.
A Developing Picture
No doubt further guidance will be issued as matters continue to develop. We at Paradigm Family Law will continue to monitor the situation and will update our readers as soon as any other major developments happen.
Paradigm Family Law have a team of experienced lawyers to help guide you through the process of divorce, just waiting to hear from you.
If you would like more details on this or want to discuss your family law matter, please do not hesitate to contact James, Frank, Evelyn or Paul. Paradigm Family Law offers a free initial consultation and our fixed fee solutions cover financial proceedings from start to finish. You can call us on 01904 217225 or email us to [email protected].